OUR STORY

Guiding Star began with a belief about how people should be treated.

We opened Guiding Star Insurance on October 16, 2023, starting from scratch in Jackson, Tennessee. Denise brought decades of insurance experience. Johnathon brought a background in technology and small-business ownership. Together, we wanted to build an agency where service and community involvement shaped the way we did business.

Service was the starting point.

For Denise, owning an agency was a longtime goal. After more than 30 years in insurance, she knew how much the relationship mattered to the person buying a policy. People needed someone who would answer their questions, explain their options, and remain involved after the paperwork was finished.

Denise wanted the freedom to give clients the time, attention, and follow-through she believed they deserved. Opening our own independent agency meant we could set those priorities ourselves.

From the beginning, we agreed that needing a sale could not be the reason to recommend a policy. Even when commissions were our entire agency income, we were willing to turn down business when we did not believe the policy was a suitable fit. Service came first, including when that meant walking away from a sale.

We built it together, one step at a time.

Guiding Star began as a home-based agency, without an existing book of business. We were also running another local business at the time. Denise sometimes worked from that location, and we occasionally met insurance clients there while Johnathon studied for his property and casualty insurance license.

We sold the other business in February 2024 and continued building Guiding Star. Around October of that year, we moved the agency from our home into an office.

Our responsibilities developed around our different strengths. Denise led the insurance and client-service side. Johnathon focused on operations, technology, marketing, and the work involved in building a new business. Both of us were involved from the start.

We chose to invest in our community first.

During our first years, we chose to put resources into local nonprofits and community involvement rather than paid advertising campaigns. We built relationships, volunteered, supported causes we cared about, and allowed the agency to grow through personal connections and referrals.

That choice reflects how we believe a business should operate. Giving back has value of its own. We want to contribute to the community we share, including helping people who may never become our clients.

Johnathon’s involvement with the Greater Jackson Chamber’s Ambassadors and Leadership Jackson has provided opportunities to serve, learn from other local leaders, and work alongside people who care about Jackson’s future. Denise has also participated in the Ambassador program.

As Guiding Star grows, we intend to preserve the independence that lets us make those decisions ourselves. We want service, relationships, and community involvement to remain central to the business we are building.

The name reflects what we hope to contribute.

We chose Guiding Star because we wanted to help people find their way through decisions that can feel unfamiliar. Insurance was where that work began, but our idea extended beyond policies.

Through community involvement, charitable giving, and everyday connections, we want to help people find useful information, resources, and opportunities. Sometimes that means an insurance conversation. Sometimes it means connecting someone with a person or organization better equipped to help.

We want people to feel comfortable bringing us a question, whether we can help directly or connect them with someone who can. That is the purpose behind the name Guiding Star.

We’re here when you have questions.

Whether you’re reviewing existing coverage, considering a change, or simply trying to understand your options, we’re happy to start with a conversation.